|
Introduction to the Pattern System
Jay
Earley, PhD
The
Pattern System is a way of understanding your personality in a way that
can lead directly to psychological healing and personal growth. It also
helps you to understand other people—why they respond as they do, what
makes them tick. It gives you a much more detailed understanding of
yourself than other personality systems that assign you a personality
type (or a few types).
Once
your have understood the Pattern System and explored yourself according
to its model, you will come away with a comprehensive map of your
psyche. You will be able to see your strengths and your defenses, your
places of pain and how you compensate for them. You will understand the
structure of your inner conflicts and see the leading edge of your
growth. The Pattern System will make clear what you need to explore next
to resolve the issues that are most important to you. You will know
where there is underlying pain, shame, or fear that must be healed. You
will know which psychological capacities you can develop (or are already
developing) to make your life happier and more productive.
The
Pattern System enables you to understand each of the parts of
your psyche, sometimes called subpersonalities. You can think of them as
little people inside you. Each has its own perspective, feelings,
memories, goals, and motivations. For example, one part of you might be
trying to lose weight, and another part might want to eat whatever you
want. We all have many different parts, such as the procrastinator, the
lover, the inner critic, the lonely child, the rebel, the caretaker, and
so on. These have been documented by many different schools of
psychotherapy.[1][1]
The
most effective of these schools, and I believe, the cutting edge in
psychotherapy today, is
Internal Family Systems therapy (IFS). The Pattern System
works hand and hand with the
IFS model, though it is compatible with most approaches to therapy. As I
explain the Pattern System in this article, I will introduce those IFS
concepts needed to understand it.
The
Pattern System addresses a number of dimensions of psychological
functioning, such as power, self-perception, conflict, support,
intimacy, emotion, safety, and risk. In each dimension the Pattern
System shows what your primary issues are, what parts are typically
involved, and what the psychological dynamics are behind each issue. It
also shows what healthy attitudes and behavior are like and how to get
there. Let’s look at a detailed example of one dimension, Work,
to show how they are structured.
Bill’s Work Patterns
Bill
is working on an big new marketing project. He spends long hours
every day and has very little time with his wife and young son. When
friends ask him why he is working so hard, when his wife asks him why
she never sees him, he says, “I want to get ahead. I want to get a quick
promotion and become highly successful.” However, when looked at
objectively, 50 hours a week would be enough in Bill’s company for him
to do quite well, but Bill regularly puts in 60-70 hours, often going
back to work on the weekends. Few people at his firm are doing this,
even people who are successfully moving up the ladder. Bill sometimes
skips meals. He occasionally works late into the night, even when there
is no deadline the next day. He is often so tired the next day that the
quality of his work suffers. There
is something driving Bill that goes beyond what is really needed for his
dreams of success. Sometimes his striving even gets in the way of his
success. It certainly gets in the way of the rest of his life.
When
Bill started exploring himself psychologically, he discovered that there
was a part of him that drove him to work so hard. This part felt that is
was crucial for Bill to devote every waking hour to work. It had to make
sure that Bill was competent and very successful. This is an example of
the Striving Pattern. This pattern has to do with striving for
success and the feeling of competence. Striving means making a great
deal of effort, often working so much that family, leisure, and health
suffer. Sometimes it means being so goal oriented that you don’t really
enjoy the work. Striving can involve choosing work or goals that have
more to do with money, power, security, or self-esteem than creativity,
purpose, or enjoyment. You might think about whether or not you have a
Striving Pattern, and if so, what yours is like.
Striving comes from a need for success that will ward off painful
feelings. Each dimension in the Pattern System is structured around a
Need and a Threat. The Need is a healthy
capacity or experience that you want, and the threat is something that
can cause you pain. In the Work Dimension, the Need is for
competence and the Threat is failure. Each pattern in this
dimension involves an attempt to feel competent or avoid failure, or both.
Bill
has a second part with a major role in his psychological dynamics around
work. When Bill was in his early years of high school, he wasn’t a high
achiever; quite the opposite. He spent his time having fun rather than
doing his homework. He watched a lot of TV. He hung out with friends. He
did just about anything except his school work. When he had an important
project, he would procrastinate and then end up with a rush job that got
a poor grade. Sometimes he didn’t do his homework at all.
This
behavior came from an entirely different part of Bill. This part wanted
to avoid doing anything where he would be graded or evaluated. It was
afraid of failure, and it dealt with this fear by avoiding projects that
could involve failure—virtually all school and work projects. This, of
course, was unconscious. If you had asked Bill why he wasn’t doing his
homework, he would have said he didn’t feel like it.
This
is an example of the Procrastinating Pattern, which involves
staying away from action of the sort that is
evaluated. It is
clearly an attempt to avoid the Work Dimension Threat, which is failure.
If you are run by a Procrastinating Pattern, you
avoid really engaging in projects. Or you delay your work in ways
that makes things hard for you or your co-workers.
Some people procrastinate by being indecisive; others
are forgetful, timid,
or passive. Some procrastinate by distracting themselves with
other things. Some just never think they could do anything to make their
life better.
Procrastination is involved any time that you would like to do something
or plan to do something, and then don’t follow through on it. Whenever
a part resists taking action to move your life forward, when
it puts things
off or get confused about how to proceed, you wonder why life seems
to be passing you by. It is important to realize that
a Procrastinating Part has a positive intent for you. It is trying to
protect you from the shame of failing. Even though this strategy doesn't
work, it is important to appreciates this part's efforts on your behalf.
Think about whether you have a Procrastinating Pattern and what
form it might take. For a detailed article on the Procrastination
Pattern, see
http://www.earley.org/Patterns/procrastination.htm.
When
Bill got into his junior year of high school,
he realized that he wanted
to get into a good college, so the Striving Part became dominant in
Bill’s psyche, and Bill worked hard through the rest of high school and
college. Triggered by a major setback at work during his 20’s, Bill’s
Procrastinator took over again for a time. But after a while the Striver
re-asserted itself, and Bill has been working hard ever since.
However, that doesn’t mean the Procrastinator has disappeared. It is
constantly there in the background of his psyche. Whenever a new project
comes up, the Procrastinator wants to avoid it, and the Striver
fights with the Procrastinator to get Bill working.
We
can represent these two patterns along with the Need and Threat in the
Work Dimension as follows (more will be filled in shortly):
Healthy Capacities
These
problematic patterns are not the whole story in this dimension. We also
have parts that function in healthy ways. After Bill has worked through
the issues that impel his parts to strive and avoid, they will also
function well.
Let’s
look at an example of this. Sarah has a part of her
that accomplishes a great
deal. She loves her work and feels good about what she gets done and how
well she does it. She doesn’t avoid doing what is needed, but she
doesn’t work obsessively either. This is an example of a healthy
capacity, the Competent Capacity. Striving is
really an extreme of
Competence. If you have a Striving Pattern it simply
means that you are taking your Competent Capacity to an extreme that
doesn't work for you. And
conversely, Competence is a healthy version of Striving. Competence
involves working in a way that is satisfying and successful and doing
this in a way that is relaxed, confident, and balanced with the rest of
your life. This is the way we naturally function, when we aren’t driven by
an extreme part. It obviously meets the Need in this
dimension for competence.
There
is also a healthy version of Procrastination, called the Easy
Capacity. Ease means functioning in life with ease and relaxation,
not being overly attached to outcome, being present in each moment while
still taking care of business. Sarah has the Easy Capacity as well as
the Competence Capacity in her work. They support each other. The Easy
Capacity means that your work flows in a pleasurable, easy way as you
accomplish things. You allow yourself to take time off for rest and fun
but not in a way that prevents you from accomplishing what is needed.
You are present and open and at ease while you work, and this adds to
your enjoyment of the activity.
Procrastination is different from Ease in that
you take it easy to such an extent that you don’t function well. You
devote yourself too much to relaxation and recreation without foreseeing
the consequences.
We can now fill in more of the Work Dimension.
The
capacities (Easy and Competent) are complementary;
that is why they are in the same circle. They work
together by supporting each other in being healthy. The goal in each
dimension is to have both healthy capacities operating. To have a
Competent Capacity, you must also have some amount of the Easy Capacity.
If you were Competent without any Ease, that would really be a Striving
Pattern, like Bill. Similarly, to have an Easy Capacity, you must also
have some Competence. If not, you would really be Procrastinating.
This graphic shows you what is needed to transform a
pattern and therefore what capacities to develop in yourself. For each
pattern, you need to develop the complementary capacity
on the other side of the chart. So to transform
Striving, you need to develop more Ease, and to transform
Procrastination, you need to develop more Competence.
This is shown in the following graphic:
Even if you have a pattern strongly, that doesn’t
mean that it operates all the time. Bill’s Striving Pattern is activated
at work. When he is home, he is able to be much more relaxed. Even when
engaged in a work-like activity, such as planning a family holiday, Bill
does it in an easy, competent way. In that situation, he exhibits the
healthy capacities in the Work Dimension.
Each of your patterns and capacities is activated under
certain circumstances and not others. It is triggered by certain people,
or certain types of people. A certain pattern may be activated by men,
or by situations where you are being observed, or by large groups of
strangers, or by angry people. A certain capacity might be activated by
intimate one-on-one situations or by challenges.
So to truly understand your personality, you must not only know
your patterns and capacities but under what circumstances they are
activated.
Polarized Patterns
The Procrastinating and Striving Patterns are
polarized with each other. This is represented by the
double headed arrow in the graphic. Remember how Bill's Procrastinating and
Striving parts often fight each other to determine how Bill is going to
act. The Striver wants him to work very hard and the Procrastinator
wants him to avoid work. They act in extreme ways partly because each
one is trying to compensate for the extreme behavior of the other. The
Striver feels forced to overwork not only because of a fear of failure
but because of a fear of procrastination. It is afraid that if it lets
up at all, the Procrastinator will take over, and all would be lost. If
the Striver considered relaxing, it is afraid that Bill would be plunged
into the laziness of the Procrastinator. And since this has happened in
the past, the Striver has reason for this fear.
The Procrastinator, on the other hand, is reacting to
the Striver. It is sick and tired of Bill’s working to death. It longs
for a rest and some fun. So it is constantly fighting with the Striver
to lighten up and relax. It rebels loudly against the tyranny of the
Striver. His procrastination isn’t just from a fear of failure, it is
also a protest against overworking. Yet the more it rebels, the more it
scares the Striver and the more obsessive the Striver becomes,
threatening the Procrastinator even more. So these two parts make each
other more extreme.
In IFS, this is called polarization. The two
polarized parts are not only in conflict, but they scare each other, and
each feels justified in its extreme behavior because it has to
compensate for the extremes of the other. This is
shown here:
Our culture pushes people in the direction of
Striving. It is built into our educational system and especially our
corporate culture. This encourages the development of a Striving Pattern
in some people and creates reactive Procrastination in others.
If you have both Striving and Procrastinating
Patterns, are they polarized in your psyche? How do they fight each
other? How do they trigger each other to be more extreme?
Exile Patterns
There
is even more to the story of the patterns in the Work Dimension. Let’s see
this by continuing with Bill. In the course of his therapy, Bill got to
know his Striving part more fully. A good way to get to know our parts
is to hear from them using creative methods
developed by IFS and find out what
their concerns and goals are. In the process of doing this, Richard
Schwartz, the founder of IFS, learned that each one of our parts has a
positive intent for us. No matter how misguided and even destructive its
behavior, each of your parts is acting the way it does in an attempt to help you
in some way, usually to protect you from some kind of pain.
As
Bill got to know his Striving part, he got curious about why it pushed
so hard. It said that it was very important that Bill be a big success.
He asked it what it was afraid would happen if he didn’t work so hard.
(This is a crucial question in IFS.) The part said it was afraid that
Bill would be a failure, that he would be seen as incompetent and end up
as a nobody. Bill’s Striver is what IFS calls a manager part. The
job of managers is to take care of navigating the external world and to
avoid pain.
Through further exploration, Bill discovered that his Striving part was
trying to protect him from the pain of a child part of him that actually
feels incompetent and like a failure. This is an exile. Exiles
are in pain that comes from childhood. Managers try to keep exiles pushed under
where their pain can’t be felt. Exiles, on the other hand, want to get
out. They want their pain to be heard and hopefully healed.
Bill
took some time to get to know this exiled part of him. Bill felt
inadequate as a child because he grew up in a town where sports were
everything, and he wasn’t good at sports. He was also criticized a lot
by his father when he couldn’t do things that any child would have a
hard time doing, and this made him feel like a failure. This
caused Bill to have
low self-esteem and feel iincompetent, which is an example of the
Inadequate Pattern. This pattern involves feeling that you aren’t OK because
you can’t do something, or because you can’t do it well enough or can’t
succeed. It means feeling that there is something wrong with you because
you aren’t smart enough or strong enough, outgoing enough or beautiful
enough, for example. You
feel that you don't measure up; you
can’t make the grade. Each person’s Inadequate part will have somewhat
different fears and a different history. Some may feel inadequate in
certain areas of life (such as dealing with new people) and not in
others (such as accomplishing tasks), or vice versa.
In
the Pattern System, the pain of an exile is a result of the Threat in
that Dimension. So in the Work Dimension, the Inadequate Pattern is a
result of failure or being made to feel like a failure in childhood.
Having an Inadequate Pattern is not the same as recognizing your
objective limitations. We all have limitations on what we can do and be
in the world. We only have so much talent or intelligence or whatever it
takes to be successful in a certain endeavor. To recognize this is
obviously good. If we accurately recognize what we can and can’t do, and
we don’t feel bad about ourselves, this is not the Inadequate Pattern.
It is just being realistic and wise
Bill’s Inadequate Part was unconscious. In fact, it was kept out of
consciousness and deeply buried by the Striving Part. The Striver felt
that if it worked hard enough and was successful enough, it could keep
the Inadequate Part hidden forever. That was its goal, to protect Bill
from the pain of the Inadequate Part. That is why it worked so hard,
even harder than was really necessary for success. This was not a
rational decision by Bill. The real reasons for his striving were
unconscious. It was driven by a desperate need to exile his feelings of
inadequacy.
Bill’s Procrastinator was also trying to protect against the Inadequate
Part, but it used a completely different strategy. It wanted to avoid
feeling inadequate by avoiding any work that could fail. Of course, this
backfired. It actually led to the feeling of inadequacy it
was trying
to circumvent. This often happens with parts; they have a narrow
perspective that prevents them from seeing the results of their
behavior.
Patterns can be transformed by getting permission from the manager (the
Procrastinator or the Striver) to get to know the exile involved (the
Inadequate Part), and then healing the pain that the exile is carrying.
Then the manager can relax and take on a healthier role in the psyche
because its no longer needs to protect against the exile. IFS has a very
effective method for helping exiles to let go of the burdens they carry
from childhood (see
Introduction to IFS Therapy). The Pattern System shows the
relationships between the managers and the exiles they protect in each
dimension, thus pointing to way toward the healing that is needed.
We can now say more about the relationship between
Exile Patterns and Capacities. Ease is a capacity we are all born with;
it gets blocked when you develop the Exile Pattern of Inadequacy.
Therefore when you do the internal work to heal the Inadequacy Pattern,
the Easy Capacity natural emerges, especially after the Striving Part
relaxes. The same is true for the Competent Capacity; this emerges
naturally after healing the Inadequacy Pattern. We can show these additional relationships as follows:
You
might want to think about whether or not you have an Inadequate Pattern
and what form it takes for you. What do you feel you are lacking? What
do you think you can’t do? How does that make you feel?
In
this article I have just provided short descriptions of these patterns
and capacities. Much more could be said about each one. In fact, one of
the advantages of the Pattern System is that we can really tell you a
lot about each pattern—the various forms it can take, how it
may behave, how to
detect it, how it may affect your life, what it feels like in your body,
what it may be trying to do for you, what parts it might be protecting, how
it interacts with other parts and other people, and how to heal it. We
can also tell you how to most effectively relate to people with a given
pattern. With exile patterns, we can also tell you where they may have
come from in your childhood. With capacities, we can
tell you what they feel
like experientially, what they add to your life, and how to develop them
to higher levels, including spiritual development.
By exploring your patterns and capacities in a given
dimension, you end up with a comprehensive understanding of your strengths
and blocks, the dynamics between your parts, and your underlying
issues.
This provides a roadmap to the work you need to do to heal your parts,
resolve your issues, and enhance your healthy functioning.
Other Dimensions
There
are many dimensions in the Pattern System. They all have a structure
similar to that of the Work Dimension. Each one has two complementary
capacities and two polarized patterns that are extremes of those
capacities. And each one has an Exile Pattern. To
illustrate this, let’s look briefly at one
other dimension, the Self-perception Dimension.
In
this realm, one healthy capacities is Self-esteem, which involves
feeling valuable in an intrinsic way that doesn’t depend on outward
success or responses from others. The other capacity is Self-exploring,
which involves being willing to look at yourself realistically,
including both your strengths and your blocks and what you need to work
on.
The
extreme version of Self-esteem is Pride, which involves being
obsessed with your self-esteem and your positive
qualities. It means
depending on your performance or
achievement to feel good about yourself. It often means showing off how great you
are. It may involve an exaggeration of your good qualities and a
need to feel better than others. This is an attempt to protect against
the exile pattern Deficiency, which involves believing that there
is something wrong with you, having low self-esteem and feeling ashamed,
guilty, or worthless. The extreme version of Self-exploring is
Self-judging, where
you don't like what you see
when you explore yourself. This is paradoxically often an attempt to
avoid the feeling of Deficiency.
We
can graphically represent this realm as follows:
|
The Self-Perception Dimension |
You can see that the Self-perception Dimension is
laid out similarly to the Work Dimension. The other dimensions also have
a similar form. Some of the interpersonal dimensions in the Pattern
System are power, support, care, responsibility, intimacy,
safety, honesty, and trust. Some of the other dimensions are purpose,
energy, emotion, clarity, risk, action, and pleasure.
Conclusion
By
exploring yourself and determining your patterns and capacities in each
dimension, you can get a map of your psyche that will
help you in working through your issues and becoming more fulfilled and
successful in your life. By understanding each of the dimensions and
patterns, you can also become wiser in observing and responding to other
people.
This
article has introduced the Pattern System by focusing on just one
dimension. Future writings will describe each dimension, capacity, and
pattern in more detail. For
current articles see
http://www.earley.org/Patterns/pattern_frame.htm. Look for workshops
and classes on the Pattern System in 2007, both in the San Francisco Bay
Area and by telephone.
|